Must: Obligation vs. Deduction
By: Mohammad Ali Ghoveh Nodoushan/ Lingoneed
The modal verb must has two main uses.
1. Obligation. Must means “have to”: She must go now.
2. Logical deduction. Must can also be an auxiliary verb showing that we are almost sure something is true or has happened, based on the evidence we have. In this meaning it takes two time forms.
Past: must have + past participle (V3). We use it when the evidence points to something that already happened.
•     She must have studied hard. (Her exam result is good, so she very probably studied hard.)
Present: must be + V-ing, or must be + adjective. We use it for something we believe is happening now.
•     She must be dancing. (We gave her good news, but we can’t see her reaction. We’re almost sure she’s dancing with joy right now.)
•     She must be happy. (Describing her state at this moment.)
Extra notes
•     With stative verbs, must can also be followed by the base verb: He must know the answer.
•     For the negative deduction, use can’t (or couldn’t), not mustn’t: She can’t be at home. Her car isn’t here. Mustn’t means prohibition: You mustn’t park here.
