Relative Clauses and WH Relative Pronouns
By: Mohammad Ali Ghoveh Nodoushan/ Lingoneed
who, whom, whose, which, that, where, when, why: how they are formed and what rules they follow
What Is a Relative Clause?
A relative clause is a small clause that gives more information about a noun and comes right after that noun. It begins with a relative pronoun such as who, whom, whose, which, that, or a relative adverb such as where, when, why. Most of these begin with wh-, which is why we often call them WH-words (that is the exception, but it works in the same system).
Example:
• The man who lives next door is my uncle.
Here, who lives next door is the relative clause, and it tells us more about the man. The noun that the clause describes is called the antecedent.
How Is a Relative Clause Formed?
The easiest way to understand relative clauses is to combine two sentences. The steps are always the same:
1. Write the two sentences side by side. They must share one noun (or idea).
2. In the second sentence, find the shared word.
3. Replace it with the correct relative pronoun.
4. Move the relative pronoun to the beginning of the second sentence.
5. Insert the second sentence right after the shared noun in the first sentence.
Example 1: the relative pronoun as subject (who)
• The man is my uncle.
• The man lives next door.
Step 3: replace The man in the second sentence with who: who lives next door
Step 5: place it right after the man:
• → The man who lives next door is my uncle.
Example 2: the relative pronoun as object (which)
• The book is interesting.
• I bought the book yesterday.
We build the second sentence with which. Important: which must move to the front of the clause, even though the object normally comes at the end of a sentence:
• I bought which yesterday → which I bought yesterday
• → The book which I bought yesterday is interesting.
Example 3: possession (whose)
• The woman is a doctor.
• Her car is red.
Here her (a possessive adjective) is replaced by whose, but the noun after it (car) stays in place:
• → The woman whose car is red is a doctor.
The Rule for Each Pronoun
| Pronoun | Used for | Example |
|---|---|---|
| who | people, as subject | The student who won the prize is my sister. |
| whom | people, as object (formal) | The teacher whom I respect retired. |
| whose | possession, for people and sometimes things | The company whose website crashed lost money. |
| which | things and animals | The phone which I lost was new. |
| that | people and things, only in defining clauses | The film that we watched was long. |
| where | place | This is the city where I was born. |
| when | time | I remember the day when we met. |
| why | reason (after reason) | That is the reason why he left. |
Relative adverbs follow the same two-sentence principle:
• The city is beautiful. I was born in the city. → The city where I was born is beautiful. (where = in which)
• The day was unforgettable. We met on that day. → The day when we met was unforgettable.
• The reason is simple. He left for that reason. → The reason why he left is simple.
Omitting the Relative Pronoun
If the relative pronoun is the object of the clause, and the clause is defining, it can be omitted:
• The book (which / that) I bought is interesting.
• The man (whom / who / that) I met was friendly.
But if the relative pronoun is the subject, it can never be omitted:
• The man who lives next door is my uncle. ✔
• The man lives next door is my uncle. ✘
Prepositions in Relative Clauses
When the verb or noun inside the clause needs a preposition, there are two options:
• Informal (more common): the preposition stays at the end: The house (that) I live in is old.
• Formal: the preposition moves to the front with the pronoun, and only which or whom can be used: The house in which I live is old.
In the formal pattern, that and who cannot be used, and the pronoun cannot be omitted.
Defining and Non-defining Clauses
Defining clauses identify the antecedent, and the sentence would be incomplete without them. They have no commas, and that can be used.
• The students who study hard pass the exam. (Only the students who study hard.)
Non-defining clauses add extra information, and removing them does not damage the sentence. They are set off with commas, never use that, and the pronoun cannot be omitted.
• My brother**,** who lives in Tehran**,** is a pilot. (I have only one brother, and he happens to live in Tehran.)
Commas actually change the meaning. Compare:
• My sister who lives in Shiraz is a nurse. (I have several sisters; the one in Shiraz is a nurse.)
• My sister**, who lives in Shiraz,** is a nurse. (I have one sister.)
Additional Points
1. which referring to a whole clause: sometimes which refers to the whole previous clause, not just one noun. This is only possible with a comma:
• He passed the exam**, which** surprised everyone.
2. what and clauses with no antecedent: what means “the thing that” and carries its own antecedent:
• What I need is time. (= The thing that I need is time.)
whoever, whatever and whichever work in the same way.
Common Mistakes for Persian Speakers
1. Repeating the pronoun: In Persian we say “کتابی که آن را خریدم” (the book that I bought it), but English does not add an extra pronoun.
• The book which I bought it ✘
• The book which I bought ✔
2. Using that after a comma: My car, that is old, ... ✘ → My car**, which** is old, ...
3. Separating the clause from its antecedent: the relative clause should come right after the noun it describes.
Summary
• A relative clause is built by combining two sentences: the shared word in the second sentence is replaced by a relative pronoun, which moves to the front of the clause.
• who/whom for people, which for things, whose for possession, that for both (defining only), where/when/why for place, time and reason.
• An object pronoun can be omitted in defining clauses; a subject pronoun never can.
• Commas show the type of clause and change the meaning.
